Request a Quote



It just takes a minute to let us know what you're looking for.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Request a Quote

Some of the Most Bizarre Insurance Claims Ever Filed

Insurance companies receive hundreds of thousands of claims each year, most of which fit a common profile and don’t raise too many eyebrows.

But every now and then an event occurs that couldn’t possibly have been predicted in a risk assessment or computed by an algorithm.

Insurance provides people and businesses with the security of being protected, no matter how unusual the circumstances may be. So having said that, here are just a few of the most bizarre claims Insurance Companies have seen through the years.

Diesel, unleaded or anti-dandruff?

bizarre insurance claims
Shampoo won’t become to newest alternative fuel anytime soon (Credit: PixaBay)

Anyone who’s stepped into the shower and realised they’ve ran out of body wash knows that shampoo will do the trick in a pinch, but unfortunately the same can’t be said for fuelling a car.

According to Northern Ireland-based insurance firm Autoline, one female customer found this out the hard way when she accidentally poured a bottle of shampoo into her vehicle’s fuel tank and had to make a claim with her provider.

Dentures ahoy!

bizarre insurance claims
One customer wasn’t smiling anymore when his teeth went overboard (Credit: PxHere)

It’s been said that buying the right insurance is like pulling teeth, but according to insurance comparison website Compare.com, one customer found the opposite when he actually lost his.

After taking out lost baggage insurance for a cruise, the customer made a bizarre claim after he vomited over the side of the ship and lost more than his last meal when his dentures followed it into the sea – lucky for him it was approved.

Third-party, fire and stuck in concrete

bizarre insurance claims
Concrete can be devastating for a vehicle (Credit: Flikr/Dhaun)

Allianz has had some weird insurance claims come through the pipeline in 2019, but one of them really takes the cake.

The insurer says a “mishap” from a concrete mixer resulted in 69 vehicles becoming encased in the stuff.

It didn’t report whether or not the claim was paid but we can safely assume the mishap wasn’t specified in the policies of the tradesperson or vehicle owners.

A plumb job

bizarre insurance claims
Added pressure set the boiler on a journey of destruction (Credit: PxHere)

Boiler repairs can be a pain for homeowners, so much so that they may attempt a fix themselves, but the details of one insurance claim should convince them to leave it to a professional.

According to Autoline, one man attempted an amateur plumbing job and got more than he bargained for when a build up of pressure caused his boiler to explode with enough force to blast out of the house and damage several parked cars.

The miracle of birth

bizarre insurance claims
There’s no report on whether the iPhone ever resurfaced (Credit: PxHere)

Giving birth should be a momentous occasion, but the experience of one farmer from Devon, UK, who helped one of his cows in the delivery process, found that life gives – but it can also take away.

According to Compare.com, the man had to claim on the loss of his iPhone as he said he’d left it in the cow.

Presumably his insurer didn’t wish to investigate further as they paid out in full.

Armchairs to ashes, drawers to dust

bizarre insurance claims
There had to be a reason for the ‘dog waste only’ sign (Credit: Flikr/Elliot Brown)

Dog-waste bins don’t come with a sign warning against depositing fireworks into them – but after this insurance claim, perhaps they should.

Allianz received a claim when a lit sparkler stupidly binned among the muck caused a fire that spread to a nearby furniture store, reducing it to ash.

A raid on sanity

bizarre insurance claims
One burglar was left with mental scars a huge payout (Credit: Piqsels)

Crime doesn’t pay.

At least that’s what the legal system would like us to think, but the experience of one very wealthy burglar says differently.

The thief-in-question robbed the house of a couple away on holiday, only to be foiled by their faulty garage door.

After being trapped in the garage for a week with his ill-gotten gains, surviving on dog food and carbonated beverages, the couple returned and he made his escape.

Broken by the ordeal, the burglar filed an insurance claim for mental anguish against the couple and was paid out $1m.